RENEWALSREDEEM VOUCHERREPORT A CLAIM
Redeem Voucher
Renewals
Report a claim

New for Old vs Market Value Caravan Insurance Explained

When arranging caravan insurance, one of the most important decisions you’ll make is whether to choose New for Old cover or Market Value cover. While both options provide protection if your caravan is stolen, damaged, or written off, the amount you receive following a claim can be very different.

Understanding the difference can help ensure you’re not left out of pocket if the unexpected happens.

In this guide, we’ll explain how each type of caravan insurance works, the advantages and disadvantages of both, and how to decide which option is right for your caravan.

What Is New for Old Caravan Insurance?

New for Old caravan insurance means that if your caravan is stolen or declared a total loss, your insurer will replace it with a brand-new equivalent model rather than paying its depreciated value. 

For example:

  • You purchase a new touring caravan for £25,000.
  • Five years later, it’s stolen.
  • The current market value is £18,000.
  • With New for Old cover, you could receive a brand-new equivalent caravan worth the current replacement cost, subject to policy terms and conditions.

This type of cover is particularly popular among owners of newer caravans who want maximum financial protection.

Benefits of New for Old Cover

  • Protects against depreciation
  • Provides the cost of a new equivalent model
  • Greater financial security after a total loss
  • Ideal for newer caravans
  • Offers peace of mind when investing in a high-value caravan

Potential Drawbacks

  • Higher insurance premiums
  • Often restricted to caravans below a certain age
  • You must insure the caravan for its full replacement value to avoid underinsurance. 

What Is Market Value Caravan Insurance?

Market Value cover pays out the caravan’s value at the time of the claim, taking depreciation into account.

Using the same example:

  • You buy a static caravan for £25,000.
  • Five years later, it is stolen.
  • The caravan is now worth £18,000.
  • Your insurer would pay approximately £18,000, subject to policy terms and excesses. 

Market value is typically determined by factors such as:

  • Age of the caravan
  • Make and model
  • Condition
  • Market demand
  • Comparable sales values 

Benefits of Market Value Cover

  • Lower insurance premiums
  • Suitable for older caravans
  • Can provide cost-effective protection
  • Often preferred when replacement with a new model is not a priority

Potential Drawbacks

  • Depreciation reduces the payout amount
  • You may need to contribute your own funds to purchase a replacement caravan
  • Less protection for newer caravans

New for Old vs Market Value: What’s the Difference?

FeatureNew for OldMarket Value
Total loss payoutNew equivalent caravanCurrent caravan value
Covers depreciationYesNo
Premium costHigherLower
Best forNewer caravansOlder caravans
Financial protectionMaximumBasic
Replacement cost coveredYesNot always

The key difference is simple:

New for Old cover replaces your caravan, while Market Value cover compensates you for what it was worth at the time of loss. 

Tourer Tow

Which Type of Caravan Insurance Is Best?

The right option depends on your circumstances.

New for Old May Be Best If:

  • Your caravan is relatively new
  • You want the highest level of protection
  • You could not easily afford to replace your caravan yourself
  • You want complete peace of mind

Market Value May Be Best If:

  • Your caravan is older
  • You’re looking for lower premiums
  • You’re comfortable replacing your caravan with a similar used model
  • The cost of New for Old cover outweighs the benefit
Tourer1

Is New for Old Cover Available on All Caravans?

Not always.

Many insurers apply age restrictions to New for Old cover, meaning older caravans may only be eligible for Market Value cover. The exact age limits vary between insurers and policy types. 

It’s important to check your policy wording and discuss your options with your insurer before arranging cover.

Why Choosing the Right Valuation Matters

One of the biggest mistakes caravan owners make is underinsuring their caravan.

If you’re selecting New for Old cover, you’ll typically need to insure the caravan for the full replacement cost of a brand-new equivalent model. Failing to do so could affect your claim settlement.

Likewise, if you’re choosing Market Value cover, it’s worth reviewing your caravan’s value regularly to ensure you’re neither overpaying nor underinsured.

Static Caravan

Get the Right Caravan Insurance with Coast Insurance

At Coast Insurance, we understand that every caravan owner has different needs. Whether you’re looking for comprehensive New for Old protection or cost-effective Market Value cover, our team can help you find a policy that suits your caravan and budget.

Our experienced advisers can explain your options and help you choose the right level of cover with confidence.

Get a Caravan Insurance Quote Today

Every caravan owner has different requirements. Getting a personalised quote is the easiest way to compare cover options and see whether New for Old or Market Value insurance is the best fit for your needs. Check out our static caravan insurance and our touring caravan insurance information and FAQs. We also offer trailer tent insurance, park home insurance, and holiday lodge insurance!